I Made THE BEST Anniversary Diamond Ring Set!

Let’s dive into what 26 years of marriage looks like… in diamonds! Welcome back, gorgeous, to another By Bonnie blog where we’re all about the sparkle. For those of you new here, come on in, grab a seat, and let’s swoon over some diamonds together. Every week, we bring you the most stunning pieces, so why not make it a habit? Because honestly, who doesn’t love admiring diamonds—especially when it’s free!

Now, you’ve had a sneak peek at these stunning rings, so let’s get into all the details that make them absolutely unforgettable.

How My Client Chose Their Dream Diamond Ring Set

Let me give you the story—because I know you love the little backstories with my clients. How did they end up here? And why this exact set for their 26th anniversary? Well, let’s get into it! So, we start with a Zoom call. 

They showed me her original ring, which, by the way, was a very wide cigar band that has given her some serious finger real estate for years. Naturally, for this new set, she wanted lots of sparkle to live up to that same gorgeous statement.

She adores the Oval cut, so we first discussed a solitaire Oval on a wide band. But the story took a beautiful twist: her husband secretly arranged to surprise her with extra diamonds. And, as you saw above, we added those diamonds right into the ring, taking the sparkle up a notch (or ten!). So there you have it—an anniversary celebration that sparkles as brilliantly as 26 years together. Isn’t that fabulous?

3.50ct Oval Tapered Cathedral French Pave Ring

Alright, let’s get into the beauty of this ring, shall we? The center stone is a stunning 3.5-carat oval, completely colorless and VVS quality. And here’s the real detail lovers appreciate: the ratio is 1.47. Now, you might be thinking, “Bonnie, what’s with the ratio?” This number is all about proportions—it’s what determines that perfect, elongated look in your stone. 

If you want the full scoop on diamond ratios and why they matter, definitely check out this video where I break it all down. Because listen, this choice is huge when you’re going for an elongated stone. How it sits, the shape, and, of course, making sure all that sparkle sits right on top for maximum shine. After all, diamonds are made to be seen, right? 

Flush Diamond Band

One of their top requests for this ring? It had to sit perfectly flush. And look, anyone who knows me knows I’m the queen of flush! 

So here’s the thing—when you’re shopping for diamonds or rings online, the last thing on your mind might be how the band and ring are going to sit together. And let me tell you, that’s where so many people get tripped up.

This is your PSA: When it comes to making sure your set sits flawlessly, that’s the beauty of working with a custom jeweler. You’re designing your ring and band together so everything aligns, no unpleasant surprises. When you’re just buying a piece here, a piece there? It’s like buying a custom house, picking a sink from one place, cabinets from another, and then realizing it doesn’t fit at all. With diamonds, every detail matters, and flush is key to that perfect, polished look!

U Gallery vs Double Gallery

Celebrating 26 years of love? That’s a big one! Congrats to you both—I’m thrilled that you’re loving your set! 

So, let’s talk about this stunning, chunky band. From the start, we wanted something substantial, because real estate on the finger is everything, right? At first, we debated going a little smaller, keeping it a bit more modest so it wouldn’t overshadow, but ultimately, we decided to go all out. And look at the result—absolutely gorgeous! The wedding band itself? It’s breathtaking on its own, with each diamond a half carat. Yes, it’s that big and that beautiful.

Now, let’s chat about the gallery styles. Originally, we considered a “U” gallery, which exposes the stones more for that open, airy look. But with stones this bold, I recommended the double gallery for a bit more durability. 

For those who are curious: the double gallery just adds that extra layer of security, so these diamonds stay put even through daily wear. And it’s still completely flush with the engagement ring! 

Just look at the versatility—whether you wear it alone or paired with your engagement ring, it’s stackable and even lets you add other bands in the future. I started with a plain faceted band, and the added texture makes everything pop. Truly, this piece came out beyond amazing, and I love that you can keep playing with it, adding more bands if you like. 

Oval Diamond Ring With Halo vs Without Halo

And, of course, we went with a stunning 2.4mm French pavé band—so timeless, so sparkly, without needing to add a hidden halo. This beauty shines all on her own! 

But if you’re wondering about a hidden halo option, here’s the comparison: one with, one without. Both are absolutely gorgeous, but why did we skip it here? Because hidden or not, it’s meant to be enjoyed from every angle, and we already had plenty of sparkle going on!

If you’re just here for diamond inspo, what other anniversary sets would you love to see? Follow me on Instagram @ByBonnieJewelry, and let’s keep celebrating diamonds and love together!